Knowledge · Plant engineering
Engineering tools in plant engineering projects
What this is about
In a plant engineering project, process engineering, piping, control engineering and procurement all work with the same data: mass flows, pressures, temperatures, nominal sizes, tags. The project manager does not have to operate every tool. But he does need to know which document comes from which tool and where information gets lost. This page gives an overview.
Engineering documents and their tools
| Document | Purpose | Typical tools | Who uses it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat balance diagram | mass and energy balance, operating points per load case | Ebsilon, Thermoflow, Toolmeyer, Excel | process engineering, sales |
| Block flow diagram | overview of the main processes | drawing programs, CAD | project management, client |
| Process flow diagram (PFD) | equipment, main lines, operating data | CAD, COMOS, AVEVA, Toolmeyer | process engineering, client |
| P&ID | all valves, instruments, lines | COMOS, AVEVA, Smart P&ID, Toolmeyer | all disciplines |
| Engineering lists | lines, valves, instruments, equipment, electrical consumers | Excel, engineering databases, Toolmeyer | procurement, installation, control engineering |
| Tagging (KKS, RDS-PP) | unique designation of every component | Excel, engineering databases, Toolmeyer | all disciplines, operator |
Where projects lose time
Most projects use a separate tool for each document. Every change to an operating point then has to be transferred by hand into the downstream documents. That costs hours per change and is one of the most common sources of error in engineering. For the project manager this means: schedule and quality risks often arise not in the calculation but at the hand-overs between tools.
| Risk | Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| contradictory values in flow diagram and list | values transferred by hand | one common data model |
| forgotten follow-up changes | no overview of what is affected | automatic display of affected documents |
| duplicate or missing tags | tags maintained in several files | project-wide numbering with duplicate check |
| late realisation that a plant does not balance | balance only in basic engineering | balance already in the bid phase |
Tool classes compared
| Criterion | Heat balance simulation (e.g. Ebsilon, Thermoflow) | Engineering database and plant CAD (e.g. COMOS, AVEVA, Smart P&ID) | Spreadsheet | Toolmeyer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Focus | thermodynamics | documentation of large projects | universal | integrated engineering from diagram to list |
| Heat and pressure balance | yes | no | self-built | yes (IAPWS-IF97) |
| Flow diagrams to ISO 10628 | not the focus | yes, drawn | no | yes, derived from the balance |
| Engineering lists | not the focus | yes | by hand | yes, from the model |
| Installation | desktop | server, licence management | desktop | none, browser |
| Cost | licence, sometimes very high | high, with implementation project | low | free to start, Planner €19/month |
| Suitable for | detailed simulation, power plant optimisation | large projects, corporate standards | single calculations | bid, concept, basic engineering, small and medium-sized plants |
Selection guide for project managers
| Situation in the project | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Bid or feasibility study, quick variants | Toolmeyer: balance, flow diagram and quantities in one step |
| Small or medium-sized plant without an in-house engineering database | Toolmeyer as an integrated tool |
| Detailed power plant simulation with manufacturer data | specialised simulation software, Toolmeyer for preliminary design |
| Corporate project with a prescribed engineering system | the prescribed system; Toolmeyer for early concepts and check calculations |
| Training, onboarding new colleagues | Toolmeyer with the freely available examples |
Toolmeyer in brief
Toolmeyer is browser-based software for plant design. It calculates heat and pressure balances to IAPWS-IF97 and automatically derives the process flow diagram with valves, instruments and KKS tags. P&ID, line, valve, instrument and equipment lists are created from the same data model. If a value in the heat balance diagram changes, Toolmeyer shows which documents are affected. For project managers this means fewer interfaces, fewer transcription errors and a reliable balance as early as the bid phase.
Detailed description, scope and calculation basis: toolmeyer.de/en/plant-design-software/ · Case study deep geothermal: toolmeyer.de/en/case-studies/deep-geothermal/
Free and without registration: Steam tables to IAPWS-IF97 · PED calculator for piping and vessels · P&ID explained simply
Frequently asked questions
Does a project manager have to create the heat balance diagram himself?
No. But he should be able to read it, because it is the basis for flow diagrams, lists and purchase orders.
What is the difference between a process flow diagram and a P&ID?
The process flow diagram shows equipment, main lines and operating data. The P&ID additionally shows all valves, instruments and small-bore lines and is the basis for installation and control engineering.
Why tools with a common data model?
Because every manual transfer costs time and creates errors. A data model ensures that a value is the same in every document.
Which software do I need as a project manager in plant engineering?
For reading and checking, a PDF viewer and a spreadsheet are usually enough. Anyone who wants to calculate variants themselves or verify a bid needs a balance tool. Toolmeyer combines balance, flow diagram and lists and runs in the browser without installation.
How do I avoid inconsistencies between the flow diagram and the line list?
By generating both from the same data model instead of reconciling them by hand. Where that is not possible, a fixed check routine after every change of the operating point helps.
Is there an affordable alternative to Ebsilon or Thermoflow?
For concept, bid and basic engineering, yes: Toolmeyer calculates steady-state heat and pressure balances to IAPWS-IF97, is free to start with and costs €19 per month in the Planner tier. For transient simulations and very detailed power plant models, the large programs remain the first choice.
How do I create a heat balance diagram online?
In the heat balance tool on toolmeyer.de, drag components onto the grid, connect them and enter operating data. The balance is calculated immediately. Ready-made examples (district heating, geothermal, steam power plant) help you get started.